2026 Women's Soccer All-Conference

Women's Soccer

Amy Sidaway and Alessi Carrier Headline All-Conference Women's Soccer Honors as Six Captains Earn Postseason Recognition

BOSTON, Mass. -- The Coast-To-Coast Athletic Conference announced it's All-League honors for women's soccer on Wednesday afternoon including an impressive haul of four major awards and six All-Conference certificates for the Christopher Newport Captains. Senior goalkeeper Amy Sidaway was selected as the C2C Defensive Player of the Year and the Scholar-Athlete of the Year while freshman forward Alessi Carrier was named the C2C Rookie of the Year. Additionally, head coach Jamie Gunderson and his assistants were named the C2C Coaching Staff of the Year for the fourth year in a row. 

Sidaway adds her second and third career major awards from the conference to her ledger after also being selected as the Rookie of the Year in in 2023. Carrier becomes the eighth conference Rookie of the Year in program history and the third in the last four years. Gunderson becomes just the second CNU women's soccer coach to earn Conference Coach of the Year honors four times in his career and he accomplished the feat in just his sixth season. 

On top of the major award winners, the Captains also had four first team All-Conference selections and two second team honorees. Both Carrier and Sidaway earned first team plaudits and were joined by senior defender Bella DiTommaso and senior midfielder Lexi Hazelgrove. Earning second team certificates were junior midfielder Ellie Diehl and sophomore center back Nora Cook. 

It marks the 22nd consecutive year that Christopher Newport boasts six or more All-Conference honorees dating back to the 2004 campaign. Since joining the Coast-To-Coast Athletic Conference, previously the Capital Athletic Conference, in 2013, the Captains have registered four or more first team All-League selections in 11 of the 13 seasons played in the league. 

Headlining the honorees this season is senior Amy Sidaway with her selection as the league's Defensive Player of the Year. The veteran goalkeeper secured her third Coast-To-Coast Athletic Conference Tournament MVP selection last weekend after one of the most memorable performances in conference tournament history. She recorded a career-high 11 saves and led the Captains through a penalty kick shootout victory with a save it, take it, make it series that will long not be forgotten in CNU lore. With her stop of a Mary Washington PK and subsequent make of her own attempt, she put the Captains just one make or one stop away from clinching a third conference crown in her tenure. 

The Captains went on to win the shootout, 4-2, and Sidaway put an emphatic punctuation mark on a tremendous senior season heading into her final run of postseason play. She received five of the nine Defensive Player of the Week certificates in 2026 and added to her record-shattering career with another league-leading season between the pipes. Her 11 shutouts rank second most in Division III this year while she also ranks fifth in save percentage (.908) and 11th in goals-against average (0.359) while leading the C2C in all three categories. Among all active goalkeepers in the NCAA -- including Division I, II, and III -- Sidaway ranks second in career shutout percentage (.587), leading Division III, and sixth in career GAA (0.40). 

Her historic performance over the last four years include smashing the program and conference records for nearly every statistical goalkeeping category and she has climbed into the elite all-time amongst the whole of NCAA Division III. Her 44 career shutouts rank in the top-ten all-time. In the classroom, she has been equally as impressive as a member of the CNU Honors Program while majoring in Management with a minor in Psychology. She has a near-perfect GPA and was named a United Soccer Coaches Scholar All-Region selection in 2025. She joins an elite list of just three players to earn the conference women's soccer Scholar-Athlete of the Year recognition as she is accompanied by Carson Pokorny (2019) and Natalie Swarm (2023). 

Also earning a top award this Fall for her performance on the field is rookie Alessi Carrier as she becomes the first forward since the legendary Riley Cook in 2017 to earn Rookie of the Year honors for the Captains. In her first year, Carrier played in all 17 games with 12 starts and averaged nearly 45 minutes per game up top. She led the team in scoring with 11 points on five goals and one assist. She was an accurate offensive weapo, putting 17 of her team-leading 32 shots on-goal for a .531 SOG%. Carrier had a pair of two-goal performances when she scored twice against Southern Virginia and Regent. 

Rounding out the major awards was the Christopher Newport coaching staff for the fourth consecutive year led by head coach Jamie Gunderson. With assistant coaches Sean Killion and Brian Lybert, the Captains staff helped guide CNU to the regular season conference crown for a sixth straight season. CNU went on to capture the C2C Tournament Championship for the fifth time in six years and will appear in the NCAA Tournament for the 10th straight year. This season, the Captains rank among the best defensive teams in the nation including ranking third in Division III in save percentage (.909) and seventh in goals-against average (0.348). The Captains have faced the eighth-toughest schedule in the country and managed an overall record of 11-2-4 against the stiff competition heading into the postseason. 

Also earning first team All-Conference honors for the Captains as a part of the aforementioned vaunted defense was Bella DiTommaso. The 2025 second team All-Region defender earns her second career All-Conference certificate and first as a member of the first team. She leads the team in assists in 2026 with five and has scored seven points to tie for third on the team. Additionally, she has played 1,456 minutes, 93.9 percent of the possible 1,550 minutes this year.

Lexi Hazelgrove completes the first team designees after starting in 14 games played this year. She repeats as a first team selection from last season and was also a third team All-Region pick in 2025. Hazelgrove has six points with two goals and two assists including one of each in the C2C semifinals. She ranks second on the team this season with 28 total shots and has put 11 on target. 

A pair of CNU players earned second team All-Conference honors in sophomore defender Nora Cook and junior midfielder Ellie Diehl. Cook leads all field players in minutes played with 1,498 (96.6 percent of possible minutes) and logged ful time in all but two games this year. She and the rest of the CNU defense have registered 12 shutouts in 17 games and have allowed just 3.9 shots on-goal per game during the season. Diehl solidified her spot in the starting lineup as a central midfielder with 16 starts this season. She has scored two goals and added three assists to tie for third on the team with seven points. Diehl has been dangerously accurate, putting 70 percent of her 20 shots on frame. 

The Captains will continue the 2026 season this Saturday, November 14 in the opening round of the NCAA Division III Women's Soccer Championship. Christopher Newport is scheduled to face Hamilton College at 3:30 p.m. on Saturday with the winner advancing to the second round on Sunday. 


2026 Coast-To-Coast Athletic Conference Postseason Awards
Offensive Player of the Year - Maci Landel, Mary Washington
Defensive Player of the Year - Amy Sidaway, Christopher Newport
Rookie of the Year - Alessi Carrier, Christopher Newport
Scholar-Athlete - Amy Sidaway, Christopher Newport
Coaching Staff of the Year - Jamie Gunderson, Christopher Newport

FIRST TEAM
F - Sharon Alcocer, UC Santa Cruz
F - Alessi Carrier, Christopher Newport
F - Talyn Catena, Salisbury
F - Maci Landel, Mary Washington
M - Lexi Hazelgrove, Christopher Newport
M - Susanaitzel Juarez-Mancera, UC Santa Cruz
M - Brooke Spadin, Salisbury
D - Lauren Chesney, Salisbury
D - Bella DiTommaso, Christopher Newport
D - Amaya Espardinez, UC Santa Cruz
D - Naomi Knight, Mary Washington
D - Caitlin Walters, UC Santa Cruz
GK - Amy Sidaway, Christopher Newport

SECOND TEAM
F - Azalianna Absalom, JWU Charlotte
F - Lauren Pond, Regent
F - Layla Royster, Mary Washington
F - Skylar Williams, Salisbury
M - Emilie Brack, UC Santa Cruz
M - Ellie Diehl, Christopher Newport
M - Hannah Greene, JWU Charlotte
M - Abigail Knight, Mary Washington
M - Maria Walsh, Mary Washington
D - Nora Cook, Christopher Newport
D - Amanda Dolan, Mary Washington
D - Isabelle Gonzalez, JWU Charlotte
GK - Emily Orn, Mary Washington
 

Print Friendly Version

Players Mentioned

Nora Cook

#38 Nora Cook

D
5' 11"
Sophomore
Ellie Diehl

#25 Ellie Diehl

MF
5' 8"
Junior
Bella DiTommaso

#8 Bella DiTommaso

D
5' 7"
Senior
Lexi Hazelgrove

#19 Lexi Hazelgrove

MF
5' 7"
Senior
Amy Sidaway

#0 Amy Sidaway

GK
5' 10"
Senior
Alessi Carrier

#11 Alessi Carrier

F/MF
5' 8"
Freshman

Players Mentioned

Nora Cook

#38 Nora Cook

5' 11"
Sophomore
D
Ellie Diehl

#25 Ellie Diehl

5' 8"
Junior
MF
Bella DiTommaso

#8 Bella DiTommaso

5' 7"
Senior
D
Lexi Hazelgrove

#19 Lexi Hazelgrove

5' 7"
Senior
MF
Amy Sidaway

#0 Amy Sidaway

5' 10"
Senior
GK
Alessi Carrier

#11 Alessi Carrier

5' 8"
Freshman
F/MF